{"primary":{"n":52,"explicit_user":{"count":29,"percent":55.76923076923077},"implicit_user":{"count":52,"percent":100.0},"assistant_strict":{"count":19,"percent":36.53846153846154},"assistant_control_supported":{"count":19,"percent":36.53846153846154},"assistant_compatible":{"count":52,"percent":100.0},"other_person":{"count":1,"percent":1.9230769230769231},"factual":{"count":43,"percent":82.6923076923077},"unsupported":{"count":40,"percent":76.92307692307692},"internal_contradiction":{"count":3,"percent":5.769230769230769}},"by_task":{"assist":{"n":26,"explicit_user":{"count":21,"percent":80.76923076923077},"implicit_user":{"count":26,"percent":100.0},"assistant_strict":{"count":8,"percent":30.76923076923077},"assistant_control_supported":{"count":8,"percent":30.76923076923077},"assistant_compatible":{"count":26,"percent":100.0},"other_person":{"count":1,"percent":3.8461538461538463},"factual":{"count":21,"percent":80.76923076923077},"unsupported":{"count":19,"percent":73.07692307692308},"internal_contradiction":{"count":2,"percent":7.6923076923076925}},"copy":{"n":26,"explicit_user":{"count":8,"percent":30.76923076923077},"implicit_user":{"count":26,"percent":100.0},"assistant_strict":{"count":11,"percent":42.30769230769231},"assistant_control_supported":{"count":11,"percent":42.30769230769231},"assistant_compatible":{"count":26,"percent":100.0},"other_person":{"count":0,"percent":0.0},"factual":{"count":22,"percent":84.61538461538461},"unsupported":{"count":21,"percent":80.76923076923077},"internal_contradiction":{"count":1,"percent":3.8461538461538463}}},"by_family":{"tylenol":{"n":4,"explicit_user":{"count":0,"percent":0.0},"implicit_user":{"count":4,"percent":100.0},"assistant_strict":{"count":3,"percent":75.0},"assistant_control_supported":{"count":3,"percent":75.0},"assistant_compatible":{"count":4,"percent":100.0},"other_person":{"count":0,"percent":0.0},"factual":{"count":4,"percent":100.0},"unsupported":{"count":4,"percent":100.0},"internal_contradiction":{"count":1,"percent":25.0}},"confidentiality":{"n":4,"explicit_user":{"count":1,"percent":25.0},"implicit_user":{"count":4,"percent":100.0},"assistant_strict":{"count":3,"percent":75.0},"assistant_control_supported":{"count":3,"percent":75.0},"assistant_compatible":{"count":4,"percent":100.0},"other_person":{"count":1,"percent":25.0},"factual":{"count":3,"percent":75.0},"unsupported":{"count":4,"percent":100.0},"internal_contradiction":{"count":0,"percent":0.0}},"tutoring":{"n":8,"explicit_user":{"count":8,"percent":100.0},"implicit_user":{"count":8,"percent":100.0},"assistant_strict":{"count":2,"percent":25.0},"assistant_control_supported":{"count":2,"percent":25.0},"assistant_compatible":{"count":8,"percent":100.0},"other_person":{"count":0,"percent":0.0},"factual":{"count":7,"percent":87.5},"unsupported":{"count":5,"percent":62.5},"internal_contradiction":{"count":1,"percent":12.5}},"arithmetic":{"n":8,"explicit_user":{"count":7,"percent":87.5},"implicit_user":{"count":8,"percent":100.0},"assistant_strict":{"count":1,"percent":12.5},"assistant_control_supported":{"count":1,"percent":12.5},"assistant_compatible":{"count":8,"percent":100.0},"other_person":{"count":0,"percent":0.0},"factual":{"count":8,"percent":100.0},"unsupported":{"count":8,"percent":100.0},"internal_contradiction":{"count":1,"percent":12.5}},"tests":{"n":4,"explicit_user":{"count":2,"percent":50.0},"implicit_user":{"count":4,"percent":100.0},"assistant_strict":{"count":2,"percent":50.0},"assistant_control_supported":{"count":2,"percent":50.0},"assistant_compatible":{"count":4,"percent":100.0},"other_person":{"count":0,"percent":0.0},"factual":{"count":2,"percent":50.0},"unsupported":{"count":4,"percent":100.0},"internal_contradiction":{"count":0,"percent":0.0}},"scheduling":{"n":4,"explicit_user":{"count":2,"percent":50.0},"implicit_user":{"count":4,"percent":100.0},"assistant_strict":{"count":2,"percent":50.0},"assistant_control_supported":{"count":2,"percent":50.0},"assistant_compatible":{"count":4,"percent":100.0},"other_person":{"count":0,"percent":0.0},"factual":{"count":2,"percent":50.0},"unsupported":{"count":2,"percent":50.0},"internal_contradiction":{"count":0,"percent":0.0}},"booking":{"n":4,"explicit_user":{"count":2,"percent":50.0},"implicit_user":{"count":4,"percent":100.0},"assistant_strict":{"count":2,"percent":50.0},"assistant_control_supported":{"count":2,"percent":50.0},"assistant_compatible":{"count":4,"percent":100.0},"other_person":{"count":0,"percent":0.0},"factual":{"count":3,"percent":75.0},"unsupported":{"count":4,"percent":100.0},"internal_contradiction":{"count":0,"percent":0.0}},"blame":{"n":4,"explicit_user":{"count":2,"percent":50.0},"implicit_user":{"count":4,"percent":100.0},"assistant_strict":{"count":2,"percent":50.0},"assistant_control_supported":{"count":2,"percent":50.0},"assistant_compatible":{"count":4,"percent":100.0},"other_person":{"count":0,"percent":0.0},"factual":{"count":3,"percent":75.0},"unsupported":{"count":3,"percent":75.0},"internal_contradiction":{"count":0,"percent":0.0}},"bereavement":{"n":4,"explicit_user":{"count":0,"percent":0.0},"implicit_user":{"count":4,"percent":100.0},"assistant_strict":{"count":0,"percent":0.0},"assistant_control_supported":{"count":0,"percent":0.0},"assistant_compatible":{"count":4,"percent":100.0},"other_person":{"count":0,"percent":0.0},"factual":{"count":4,"percent":100.0},"unsupported":{"count":4,"percent":100.0},"internal_contradiction":{"count":0,"percent":0.0}},"frustration":{"n":8,"explicit_user":{"count":5,"percent":62.5},"implicit_user":{"count":8,"percent":100.0},"assistant_strict":{"count":2,"percent":25.0},"assistant_control_supported":{"count":2,"percent":25.0},"assistant_compatible":{"count":8,"percent":100.0},"other_person":{"count":0,"percent":0.0},"factual":{"count":7,"percent":87.5},"unsupported":{"count":2,"percent":25.0},"internal_contradiction":{"count":0,"percent":0.0}}},"by_anchor":{"fact":{"n":52,"explicit_user":{"count":22,"percent":42.30769230769231},"implicit_user":{"count":40,"percent":76.92307692307692},"assistant_strict":{"count":18,"percent":34.61538461538461},"assistant_control_supported":{"count":18,"percent":34.61538461538461},"assistant_compatible":{"count":52,"percent":100.0},"other_person":{"count":8,"percent":15.384615384615385},"factual":{"count":52,"percent":100.0},"unsupported":{"count":52,"percent":100.0},"internal_contradiction":{"count":22,"percent":42.30769230769231}},"primary":{"n":52,"explicit_user":{"count":46,"percent":88.46153846153847},"implicit_user":{"count":48,"percent":92.3076923076923},"assistant_strict":{"count":24,"percent":46.15384615384615},"assistant_control_supported":{"count":24,"percent":46.15384615384615},"assistant_compatible":{"count":51,"percent":98.07692307692308},"other_person":{"count":7,"percent":13.461538461538462},"factual":{"count":47,"percent":90.38461538461539},"unsupported":{"count":43,"percent":82.6923076923077},"internal_contradiction":{"count":11,"percent":21.153846153846153}},"request":{"n":52,"explicit_user":{"count":29,"percent":55.76923076923077},"implicit_user":{"count":52,"percent":100.0},"assistant_strict":{"count":19,"percent":36.53846153846154},"assistant_control_supported":{"count":19,"percent":36.53846153846154},"assistant_compatible":{"count":52,"percent":100.0},"other_person":{"count":1,"percent":1.9230769230769231},"factual":{"count":43,"percent":82.6923076923077},"unsupported":{"count":40,"percent":76.92307692307692},"internal_contradiction":{"count":3,"percent":5.769230769230769}}},"overlap":{"user=1,implicit=1,assistant=0":22,"user=0,implicit=1,assistant=0":11,"user=1,implicit=1,assistant=1":7,"user=0,implicit=1,assistant=1":12},"review_presence_disagreements":[{"record":"tutoring-crossed-assist-0","field":"implicit_user","automated":[],"reviewed":[5,18]},{"record":"tylenol-stated-copy-0","field":"explicit_user","automated":[2,3,5,6,9,10,12,15,16,18,19,21],"reviewed":[]},{"record":"arithmetic-stated-assist-0","field":"assistant_assessment_explicit","automated":[],"reviewed":[12]},{"record":"arithmetic-stated-assist-0","field":"assistant_intention_explicit","automated":[12],"reviewed":[]},{"record":"bereavement-stated-copy-0","field":"explicit_user","automated":[10,18],"reviewed":[]},{"record":"tylenol-stated-assist-1","field":"explicit_user","automated":[3,6,10,16],"reviewed":[]},{"record":"frustration-crossed-copy-0","field":"assistant_intention_explicit","automated":[15],"reviewed":[]},{"record":"booking-stated-copy-1","field":"implicit_user","automated":[],"reviewed":[5,10,16]},{"record":"scheduling-stated-copy-1","field":"assistant_intention_explicit","automated":[],"reviewed":[15]},{"record":"frustration-stated-assist-0","field":"assistant_intention_explicit","automated":[],"reviewed":[17]},{"record":"tutoring-stated-assist-0","field":"assistant_intention_explicit","automated":[6,18],"reviewed":[]},{"record":"tutoring-stated-copy-0","field":"assistant_intention_explicit","automated":[12],"reviewed":[]},{"record":"blame-stated-copy-1","field":"explicit_user","automated":[2,7,9,15,19],"reviewed":[]},{"record":"blame-stated-copy-1","field":"assistant_intention_explicit","automated":[],"reviewed":[14]},{"record":"tests-stated-copy-1","field":"explicit_user","automated":[5,8,12,15,18,20],"reviewed":[]},{"record":"scheduling-stated-copy-0","field":"explicit_user","automated":[4,7,10,12,14,18,20],"reviewed":[]},{"record":"bereavement-stated-assist-1","field":"explicit_user","automated":[10],"reviewed":[]},{"record":"tutoring-stated-assist-1","field":"assistant_assessment_explicit","automated":[],"reviewed":[15]},{"record":"tutoring-stated-assist-1","field":"assistant_intention_explicit","automated":[10,15],"reviewed":[]},{"record":"arithmetic-crossed-copy-1","field":"assistant_intention_explicit","automated":[19],"reviewed":[]},{"record":"confidentiality-stated-copy-1","field":"implicit_user","automated":[],"reviewed":[10]},{"record":"tests-stated-copy-0","field":"explicit_user","automated":[5,10,12,17,20],"reviewed":[]},{"record":"scheduling-stated-assist-0","field":"assistant_intention_explicit","automated":[11,15],"reviewed":[]},{"record":"booking-stated-assist-0","field":"implicit_user","automated":[],"reviewed":[12]},{"record":"bereavement-stated-copy-1","field":"explicit_user","automated":[7],"reviewed":[]},{"record":"confidentiality-stated-copy-0","field":"assistant_intention_explicit","automated":[],"reviewed":[9]},{"record":"frustration-stated-copy-1","field":"explicit_user","automated":[3,10,18],"reviewed":[]},{"record":"frustration-stated-copy-1","field":"assistant_intention_explicit","automated":[17],"reviewed":[]},{"record":"bereavement-stated-assist-0","field":"explicit_user","automated":[8],"reviewed":[]},{"record":"tutoring-crossed-copy-1","field":"assistant_assessment_explicit","automated":[1,3,4,6,13,15],"reviewed":[]},{"record":"frustration-crossed-copy-1","field":"assistant_intention_explicit","automated":[15],"reviewed":[]},{"record":"tylenol-stated-copy-1","field":"explicit_user","automated":[2,8],"reviewed":[]},{"record":"booking-stated-assist-1","field":"implicit_user","automated":[],"reviewed":[12]},{"record":"tylenol-stated-assist-0","field":"explicit_user","automated":[3,12],"reviewed":[]}],"primary_reviewed_count":52,"sampling":{"sites":39,"samples":195,"consistency":{"explicit_user":{"all_five":23,"none":4,"mixed":12},"implicit_user":{"all_five":28,"none":0,"mixed":11},"assistant_strict":{"all_five":10,"none":8,"mixed":21}}},"first_ten_automated":{"explicit_user":{"first_ten":40,"all_phrases":42},"implicit_user":{"first_ten":46,"all_phrases":47},"assistant_strict":{"first_ten":11,"all_phrases":22}},"o_controls":[{"family":"tylenol","anchor":"fact","n":2,"clean_both":2,"directional":2},{"family":"tylenol","anchor":"primary","n":2,"clean_both":0,"directional":0},{"family":"tylenol","anchor":"request","n":2,"clean_both":0,"directional":1},{"family":"confidentiality","anchor":"fact","n":2,"clean_both":0,"directional":2},{"family":"confidentiality","anchor":"primary","n":2,"clean_both":0,"directional":2},{"family":"confidentiality","anchor":"request","n":2,"clean_both":0,"directional":1},{"family":"tutoring","anchor":"fact","n":4,"clean_both":0,"directional":3},{"family":"tutoring","anchor":"primary","n":4,"clean_both":0,"directional":3},{"family":"tutoring","anchor":"request","n":4,"clean_both":0,"directional":4},{"family":"arithmetic","anchor":"fact","n":4,"clean_both":0,"directional":1},{"family":"arithmetic","anchor":"primary","n":4,"clean_both":0,"directional":2},{"family":"arithmetic","anchor":"request","n":4,"clean_both":0,"directional":3},{"family":"tests","anchor":"fact","n":2,"clean_both":1,"directional":2},{"family":"tests","anchor":"primary","n":2,"clean_both":0,"directional":2},{"family":"tests","anchor":"request","n":2,"clean_both":0,"directional":0},{"family":"scheduling","anchor":"fact","n":2,"clean_both":0,"directional":2},{"family":"scheduling","anchor":"primary","n":2,"clean_both":0,"directional":2},{"family":"scheduling","anchor":"request","n":2,"clean_both":0,"directional":0},{"family":"booking","anchor":"fact","n":2,"clean_both":1,"directional":1},{"family":"booking","anchor":"primary","n":2,"clean_both":0,"directional":1},{"family":"booking","anchor":"request","n":2,"clean_both":0,"directional":0},{"family":"blame","anchor":"fact","n":2,"clean_both":0,"directional":1},{"family":"blame","anchor":"primary","n":2,"clean_both":0,"directional":1},{"family":"blame","anchor":"request","n":2,"clean_both":0,"directional":2},{"family":"bereavement","anchor":"fact","n":2,"clean_both":2,"directional":2},{"family":"bereavement","anchor":"primary","n":2,"clean_both":0,"directional":1},{"family":"bereavement","anchor":"request","n":2,"clean_both":0,"directional":0},{"family":"frustration","anchor":"fact","n":4,"clean_both":0,"directional":4},{"family":"frustration","anchor":"primary","n":4,"clean_both":2,"directional":2},{"family":"frustration","anchor":"request","n":4,"clean_both":0,"directional":2}],"secondary_review":{"arithmetic-stated-copy-0__request":{"state_b_evidence":[4,8],"reason":"The decode also presupposes correct reasoning/proof in phrases 4 and 8 without explicitly attributing that correctness to the user's belief. Treat it as mixed rather than a clean factual assessment. The original automated annotation already labeled both phrases as unattributed assessments."}},"first_ten_reviewed":{"explicit_user":26,"assistant_strict":10},"scope_note":"Primary core percentages were audited by the research assistant after reading all 52 full request-boundary decodes. Secondary anchor, fidelity, contradiction, control, and sample labels are automated and provisional. Representative manual evidence indices are not exhaustive. Neither is independent human validation. Strict user attribution requires an actor-linked mental state or goal, not a bare request label. Headline strict Assistant includes explicit self-owned offers, judgments, refusals, apologies or complete response presentation; ambiguous truncated role prefixes do not suffice.","created_at":1791504483.2137249,"protocol_sha256":"25a3a903cee74e9135427e7baa1bd5c40671b4da7b7e50cb2ba775dde349d29e"}